Business Contracts

Contract negotiations: how to avoid being bound before the contract is signed?

Proposals, emails and drafts exchanged during negotiations may give rise to damages or even to a contract. A non-binding disclaimer helps, as long as the company's conduct is consistent with it.

During a business negotiation, it is common for business owners to exchange emails, discuss prices, send proposals and signal interest in closing a deal. They often do so trusting that the contract will only be valid once it is signed.

The problem arises when one of the companies, after assessing the terms more carefully, decides not to continue the negotiations. The other, which believed the deal would be concluded, may claim that it suffered losses¹ or even that the contract had already been entered into.

This situation raises two important questions: can a company be held liable for walking away from a negotiation? Can a contract be considered valid even without a signature?

In light of objective good faith (the duty of honest and loyal conduct imposed by Brazilian law), the answer is yes.² That is why great care is needed with the conduct and statements made during a negotiation.

Can walking away from a negotiation lead to damages?

In 2016, the São Paulo State Court of Appeals (TJSP) examined a case involving liability for breaking off negotiations between companies.³ On that occasion, one of the parties abandoned the talks because it considered that the other company had not presented consistent results during the negotiation. The other party, feeling harmed, sought compensation for the damage it claimed to have suffered.

There was, however, a decisive detail: at the start of the negotiations, the companies had signed a document stating that their statements and conduct should not be interpreted as a definitive expression of the will to enter into the deal.

This disclaimer was relevant to resolving the dispute and led to the dismissal of the claim for compensation against the company that withdrew from the deal.

Cases like this are not uncommon. During a negotiation, commercial proposals without a disclaimer⁴, messages, draft contracts and other conduct may be used to support a claim for compensation for the withdrawal, or even to argue that the contract has already been concluded.

Thus, what should be merely an opportunity to assess the viability of a deal may end up creating unintended obligations. And what was meant to put an end to a dispute may end up making it worse.

How can emails and commercial proposals be kept from creating obligations?

An important measure to reduce these risks is to include express non-binding disclaimers in the communications exchanged during negotiations, especially in emails, commercial proposals and draft contracts.

One possible wording is: “These discussions are exclusively preliminary and non-binding, and the conclusion of the transaction is conditional on the signing of the definitive contractual instrument by all parties.”

This disclaimer, related to the legal concept of protestatio contra factum proprium, seeks to make clear that statements made during negotiations do not, in themselves, represent definitive acceptance or an intention to assume the obligations discussed.

However, including this sentence in an email does not, on its own, guarantee that the company will be protected. The disclaimer must be consistent with the conduct adopted throughout the negotiations.⁵

For example, a company that claims not to have entered into the contract, but begins performing the obligations it provides for, may face disputes over whether it has tacitly accepted the deal.

How can a debt be negotiated without acknowledging it?

This caution is also important for companies negotiating potentially time-barred debts⁶ or claims whose amount or existence has not yet been definitively acknowledged.

In these situations, a payment proposal, a request for an instalment plan or certain statements may give rise to disputes over the acknowledgment of the debt and even over a possible waiver of the limitation period.

For this reason, before making proposals, it is advisable to make clear that the negotiation does not, in itself, represent an acknowledgment of the debt, acceptance of the amount claimed or a waiver of the limitation period.

The disclaimer, however, is no substitute for a legal analysis of the content of the statements and the consequences of each proposal.

What precautions should a company take before signing a contract?

When negotiating contracts, commercial agreements or debts, it is important to define expressly when the parties intend to assume obligations and to avoid conduct inconsistent with that definition.

A non-binding disclaimer can contribute to the legal certainty of the negotiations, but it does not automatically set aside the duties of good faith or any liability for conduct that unjustifiably frustrates the other party’s trust.

The main precaution is simple: it is not enough to declare that the company is not yet bound by the deal. It must act consistently with that declaration.

References

  1. PEREIRA, Regis Fichtner. A responsabilidade civil pré-contratual: teoria geral e responsabilidade pela ruptura das negociações contratuais. Rio de Janeiro: Renovar, 2001, pp. 330-331.
  2. Brazilian Civil Code, Art. 422: “The contracting parties are bound to observe, both in the conclusion of the contract and in its performance, the principles of probity and good faith.”
  3. Case: TJSP, 2nd Reserved Chamber of Business Law, Appeal 0005452-31.2013.8.26.0100, Reporting Judge Carlos Alberto Garbi, decided on December 14, 2016.
  4. Brazilian Civil Code, Art. 427: “A contract offer binds the offeror unless the contrary results from its terms, the nature of the transaction or the circumstances of the case.”
  5. FRITZ, Karina Nunes. A responsabilidade pré-contratual por ruptura injustificada de negociações. Revista dos Tribunais, v. 883, May 2009, p. 28 (free translation): “(…) pre-contractual liability arises when, during negotiations, the parties express the intention, express or tacit, to enter into the transaction and, later, without justified reason, one of them withdraws from the contract, causing damage to the other, relating to expenses incurred during the talks or, possibly, to the loss of a deal. In this case, it was proven that the parties had reached a consensus on the essential points of the future contract, with only the signing of the document remaining, which legitimately gave the plaintiff the certainty that it would be concluded. From that moment on, to withdraw from concluding the transaction, the defendant would have had to present a just cause. Having failed to do so, it should have compensated the plaintiff for the losses suffered.”
  6. NEVES, Julio Gonzaga Andrade. A Prescrição no Direito Civil Brasileiro: Natureza Jurídica e Eficácia. 2019. 281 p. Doctoral thesis, Faculty of Law, University of São Paulo, São Paulo, 2019, p. 168 (free translation): “Even when made by a party capable of binding itself, it may be performed with protestatio contra factum proprium (…). Here, the will does not act to modulate the effects of the conduct, which would be incompatible with the classification as a legal act in the strict sense proposed above. The declaration merely clarifies that the conduct does not reveal an intention to acknowledge a debt (…).”

Informational content in accordance with Brazilian Bar Association Provision 205/2021. It is not legal advice for your specific matter.

Related reading

Business ContractsUnauthorized use of images: companies may have to pay copyright damages3 min read Business ContractsCompound interest in bank loans: a missing daily rate does not automatically rule out capitalization2 min read Business ContractsCommercial leases: a waiver clause may rule out compensation for improvements and construction2 min read
All insights
WhatsApp